C. G. Jungs psychology was based on an authentic notion of soul but this notion was only intuitive implicit not conceptually worked out. His followers forfeit his heritage often turning psychology either into pop psychology or into a scientific clinical enterprise. It is the merit of James Hillmans archetypal psychology to have brought back the question of soul to psychology. But as imaginal psychology it cannot truly overcome psychologys positivistic personalistic bias that it set out to overcome. Its Gods can be shown to be virtualreality type gods because it avoids the question of Truth. Through what logically is the movement of an absolutenegative interiorization alchemically a fermenting corruption and mythologically a Dionysian dismemberment one has to go beyond the imaginal to a notion of soul as logical life logical movement. Only then can psychology be freed from its positivism and cease being a subdivision of anthropology and can the notion of soul be logically released from its attachment to the notion of the human being.